page title img

Joe’s Brooklyn Pizza Customer Reviews

Best selection of pizza slices in Rochester.

Chris M.

By and far the best pizza place around. I recommend going there for slices. Their stuffed/double-layered pizzas are incredible and the BBQ pizza has ghost pepper laced sauce which makes it unique and very spicy! All-around excellence; even their plain cheese pizza is amazing.

Tyler G.

I ordered lunch from Joe’s today for the staff at my office and had one of the best delivery experiences ever. Not only was the pizza on time, hot and perfectly cooked, but they added (at no charge) a medium pizza of “black garlic” on a white crust. It was a new flavor they were trying.

Fantastic Pizza, Great Customer Service

Best pizza in Rochester!!!

Victoria E.

Never had a bad experience at Joe’s. Food is always amazing. Customer service always great…today even more so.

Darren D.

Finally, a pizza place in Western New York that deserves the word Brooklyn in front of it! Excellent pizza and friendly staff.

Kristine U.

Delicious classic NY pizza! The grandmas pizza is the best.

Steve L.

I enjoyed the pizza from Joe’s. Everyone is always very friendly and helpful when it comes to the staff. I have yet to have a bad pie from them. Next time I am in town, I still stop by and grab a slice.

Great pie

We’ve been getting pizza from Joe’s Brooklyn Pizza ever since they opened – we usually order a pizza from here at least once or twice a month. The crust is crunchy but not too thick, the sauce and pepperoni have a bit of a kick to them, and the cheese is perfectly melted and stretchy like it should be.

One of our "go-to" places for pizza in Rochester.

I am from Brooklyn, but have been in Rochester for about 100 years!! Although I like the pizza in Rochester, I miss the NYC pizza I grew up with. Joe’s is as close as you can get, with the exception of Stromboli Express on East Ave…..both are great. Staff is friendly.

Guy from Brooklyn